Nonlethal options needed
Posted : Tuesday Apr 28, 2009 20:46:12 EDT
Despite millennia of investment in developing better weapons, the options remain staggeringly binary — kill or not kill.
That’s too simplistic in today’s complex world. It demands greater investment in nonlethal weapons so urgently needed in places such as Afghanistan, Iraq and Pakistan.
Needed capabilities include knockout agents, heat and sound beams, laser “dazzlers” to dissuade attackers, and nonkinetic systems that disable vehicles. But progress has been slow, despite field commanders’ calls for more humane systems.
Critics say the Pentagon’s inability to deliver working systems has prompted field commanders to seek effective commercial wares, only to find themselves stymied from procuring them.
Admittedly, nonlethal progress is also hampered by international convention. Sleep-inducing agents are banned as chemical weapons, while systems that cause temporary blindness are viewed as inhumane — grounded on twisted logic that it’s better to kill someone than blind them or put them to sleep.
Advances in warfare usually face resistance but gain acceptance thanks to visionary leadership. Unmanned systems are a good recent example.
Absent nonlethals, field commanders rely on lethal force or its threat to do their job. But while no weapon, no matter how well intentioned, will be risk-free, it only makes sense to have nonlethal options when something less than deadly force is required.
Leave a Comment
Most Viewed Stories
- Pentagon IG reviewing fatal Raptor crash
- Air Force preps flight attendants for VIP trips
- Guard general opposes A-10 removal at Ind. base
- AF Academy cadets’ commander up for 2nd star
- Marine scout snipers used Nazi SS logo
- Owner of troubled uniform store arrested
- The ‘Stan: An officer’s unvarnished view
- DoD to recommend new combat roles for women
- Report: Air Force fires men’s basketball coach
- Ala. panel: Military ID can prove citizenship
- Nellis airman killed in crash was from Ill.
- Staff sgt. offered TV tryout after viral video
- Tricare pharmacy merger worries lawmakers
Contests and Promotions
Enter our 2012 Red Carpet Contest!
Predict who will get the statues on Hollywood's big night and win a $200 Fandango Gift Card!
Click Here To Enter.
Win Tactical Night Vision Goggles!
Enter to Win the Military Times Sweepstakes!
Click Here To Enter.
Free Stickers
Click here and we'll send you a FREE AFGHANISTAN, IRAQ, VIETNAM, or DESERT STORM sticker.
Marketplace
Mil-Mall
2011 Insider's Guide To Military BenefitsThis handbook for military life includes essential information on pay and benefits, housing, education, health care and more.
Military Discounts
Save on your purchases!
In honor of your military service, you can find regular and name brand products at a special discount.






